![]() Sometimes a chosen site becomes so damaged by the birds themselves that the trees can no longer support the flock. ![]() Sometimes a roost site is destroyed by development. The question is complicated by the fact that purple martin roosts are by nature dynamic and unpredictable. “But I’ve looked at this from many different aspects, and it’s difficult to find an approach that meets everybody’s needs or desires. “If I could wave a magic wand, we would figure out how the birds could be embraced and engaged in a way that made it possible for symphony patrons and downtown businesses to coexist with the purple martins,” Terry Cook, the state director of the Nature Conservancy in Tennessee, told me. It’s hard for me to admit that, even to myself, but it’s true. I have spent nearly three decades making my own yard hospitable to songbirds, but I wouldn’t want 150,000 birds roosting in my own fragile trees. The people who are mobilizing to protect them are showing what love in action looks like.īut I sympathize with the symphony, too. The birds’ presence here - despite this city’s unplanned and poorly regulated growth, despite developers’ relentless destruction of mature trees - feels like nothing less than a miracle. I love purple martins, and it’s easy for me to understand why conservation activists might view the symphony’s decision as a betrayal of a sacred trust. ![]() Both are simply doing what their own species does best. The symphony just wants to play music again. The birds just want to gather in a safe place while they fatten up on insects for the long journey to South America. The conflict boils down to this: A magnificent gathering of birds, who are facing a host of human-created environmental stressors like habitat destruction and climate change, has in turn created a host of bird-related environmental stressors for human beings. The symphony’s plan pleases no one: not wildlife advocates, who don’t want the purple martin roost disturbed not tree advocates, who want to protect the urban tree canopy not even symphony officials, who want to go back to holding concerts before full houses. When radio station WPLN ’s Caroline Eggers first broke the news, a great hue and cry arose in the local conservation community, and far beyond it, too. Valentine and his team have decided that the best thing for everyone, purple martins included, is to cut down the severely damaged elms before the birds return and replace them with smaller trees that will make the symphony grounds a less attractive roost site. Valentine, president and chief executive of the Nashville Symphony, calls the birds “an existential threat” to his organization. No audience wants to enter a symphony hall covered in bird droppings, but closing the building during the purple martins’ next visit would cost another $4 million in lost revenue. If the birds come back this year, with the Schermerhorn fully open again, their presence will be catastrophic. Through it all, the organization has spent more than $100,000 cleaning up after the purple martins, a figure that far surpasses the donations raised for that purpose by conservation groups. Since resuming concerts last fall, it has struggled to fill seats as first Delta and then Omicron raged. During the shutdown, the organization temporarily furloughed 132 full-time staff members and more than 300 part-time employees. The pandemic has cost the Nashville Symphony $26 million in lost revenue. It was a true feel-good story at a time when everyone desperately needed to feel good about something. A fundraising campaign by the Tennessee Wildlife Federation and The Nature Conservancy in Tennessee helped pay the costs of pressure washing the limestone building. When word got out about the symphony’s troubles, though, the local conservation community stepped up. For the symphony, shuttered by the pandemic, unsure when it would ever be able to hold concerts again, the birds were pouring salt into a hemorrhaging wound. Imagine the weight of so many birds on a few dozen trees, the stench of so many bird droppings on a public plaza. The flock was a glorious sight - 150,000 birds descending from the sky night after night - but the problems they created for the cash-strapped symphony were extensive. The birds had left their nesting territories, both nearby and farther north, and were gathering in preparation for the fall migration. ![]() NASHVILLE - In the summer of 2020, a massive flock of purple martins set up camp in the trees surrounding the Schermerhorn Symphony Center, in the heart of downtown Nashville. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |